Kingston Press All articles
Investigations

The Claims Desk: Kingston’s Pothole Payouts and the Roads That Keep Coming Back

Kingston Press
The Claims Desk: Kingston’s Pothole Payouts and the Roads That Keep Coming Back

Every spring, Kingston’s highways inbox fills with the same three photographs: a wheel arch, a rim, a hole. The claims that follow are the borough’s most direct measure of what a failing road actually costs a resident — not in budget papers, but in invoices, insurance excesses and MOT advisories.

Claim records released to Kingston Press under the Freedom of Information Act give the first ward-level picture of how that money has moved in 2026. They also expose an awkward pattern: the streets that generate the most reports are not the streets that receive the most compensation, and neither map matches the council’s own repair schedule.

What the payments ledger shows

Up to the end of October 2026, the borough logged 312 claims for vehicle damage attributed to carriageway defects. Of those, 74 were settled with a payment, 168 were rejected, and the remainder were still open or had been withdrawn. The settled total came to roughly £61,400, an average of about £830 per successful claim and a figure that will be familiar to anyone who has priced a single alloy wheel and a tracking adjustment.

That is not, in local government terms, a large sum. It is smaller than a single resurfacing scheme on a secondary road. The significance lies less in the total than in the distribution.

Claims cluster heavily in the car-dependent wards at the southern and eastern edges of the borough — Chessington South, Hook and Tolworth, Old Malden — where residents commute by vehicle and where a pothole is met at speed rather than at walking pace. Yet the proportion of claims paid is highest in wards with lower claim volumes. In parts of the south of the borough, rejection rates run above 60 per cent.

Why a claim succeeds or fails

The reason is rarely the size of the hole. It is the paperwork behind it.

Under section 41 of the Highways Act 1980, the council has a duty to maintain the roads it adopts. Under section 58, it has a defence: if it can show that the highway was in a reasonable condition having regard to the traffic it carries and the resources available, and that it had a reasonable system of inspection and repair, a claim can be repudiated even where the defect is real.

In practice, that defence is built from inspection logs. If a road was walked or driven within its scheduled cycle and no defect was recorded, the council will usually reject the claim on the basis that it could not reasonably have known. If a defect had already been reported and was awaiting repair, the defence weakens considerably.

The consequence is that the compensation ledger is not a record of where the roads are worst. It is a record of where the council’s knowledge can be documented — and where it cannot.

The inspection cycle and the streets beyond it

Kingston, like most London boroughs, applies a risk-based inspection regime consistent with the national code of practice for well-managed highway infrastructure. Principal roads are inspected on the shortest cycles, secondary distributor roads less often, and lightly trafficked residential streets on the longest.

This is defensible engineering. It is also, from a resident’s point of view, an invisible hierarchy. Two streets a few hundred yards apart can be inspected twelve times a year and once every three years respectively, with no visible difference in the surface between them and no notice to the people who drive them.

Where inspection intervals are long, the section 58 defence is paradoxically strongest. A road that has not been looked at for months can still produce a valid rejection, because the council can show it was not due to be looked at. The claim is defeated not by the absence of a hole but by the calendar.

Repeat defects and the repair that does not hold

Repair schedules add a second layer of difficulty. Records supplied to Kingston Press show a median interval of 22 days between a defect being reported and a first repair being undertaken — a figure that meets the authority’s published target but conceals wide variation, with some categories of defect waiting considerably longer.

More telling is the number of locations repaired more than once within a two-year window. On a sample of streets across the borough, a substantial minority of recorded defects appear as repeat interventions at or near the same chainage. These are the roads where a permanent fix — resurfacing, drainage work, a root cause — has not been funded, and where the cycle of patch, settle, report, patch continues.

Each pass through that cycle consumes highway maintenance budget and creates a fresh opportunity for a claim. It also generates an inspection record that, in the hands of a claims handler, looks like diligence.

The residents who never claim

The most serious limitation of the payout data is what it omits. Claiming requires time, a photograph taken at the scene, a repair invoice and a certain confidence in dealing with a public authority. Residents on lower incomes, without comprehensive insurance, or without the digital access that Kingston’s reporting systems assume are systematically under-represented — a pattern this publication has documented in other contexts.

For those households, a broken suspension is not a claim. It is a bill absorbed, a journey abandoned, or a car taken off the road.

Questions the council should answer

Three things would materially improve scrutiny, and none requires new legislation.

First, publication of claim volumes, outcomes and values by ward, quarterly, alongside defect reports received in the same period. A high ratio of reports to claims in a given area is a signal worth understanding, not hiding.

Second, a public repetition register: any location repaired three or more times in two years, listed with the intervention dates and the reason a permanent repair has not been scheduled.

Third, disclosure of the inspection schedule at street level, so that residents can see the interval applying to their road and can test the section 58 defence against something they can verify.

None of this would eliminate potholes. It would establish whether Kingston is managing a road network or administering the consequences of not managing it. On the present evidence, the borough is paying out modestly, rejecting widely, and repairing the same places more than once — a claims desk doing its job, in front of a maintenance programme that is not.

All Articles

Related Articles

After the Apology: Kingston’s Ombudsman Casework and the Repetition Test

After the Apology: Kingston’s Ombudsman Casework and the Repetition Test

The Cold Perimeter: Kingston’s Gritting Routes and the Streets Beyond the Line

The Cold Perimeter: Kingston’s Gritting Routes and the Streets Beyond the Line

The Closing Hour: Kingston's Library Branches and the Quiet Rationing of Digital Access

The Closing Hour: Kingston's Library Branches and the Quiet Rationing of Digital Access